Cards listed on October 29
| Set | # | Card Title | Pro Team | College | Grade | Price | Notes | Date Added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 Leaf | 22G | Steve Van Buren | Philadelphia Eagles | LSU | PSA 3 | 302.00 | rookie card, variation with blue jersey, green sock | Oct 29 |
| 1962 Topps | 36 | Ernie Davis | Cleveland Browns | Syracuse | PSA 4 | 232.00 | rookie card, short print | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 24 | Glenn Bass | Buffalo Bills | East Carolina | PSA 7 | 77.00 | rookie card, error card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 25 | Al Bemiller | Buffalo Bills | Syracuse | PSA 7 | 79.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 26 | Wray Carlton | Buffalo Bills | Duke | PSA 7 | 83.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 27 | Tom Day | Buffalo Bills | North Carolina A and T | PSA 5 | 36.00 | rookie card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 29 | Jim Dunaway | Buffalo Bills | Mississippi | PSA 8 | 305.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 30 | Pete Gogolak | Buffalo Bills | Cornell | PSA 7 | 156.00 | rookie card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 31 | Dick Hudson | Buffalo Bills | Memphis | PSA 7 | 130.00 | rookie card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 32 | Harry Jacobs | Buffalo Bills | Bradley | PSA 9 | 1337.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 33 | Billy Joe | Buffalo Bills | Villanova | PSA 8 | 452.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 34 | Tom Keating | Buffalo Bills | Michigan | PSA 6 | 78.00 | rookie card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 35 | Jack Kemp | Buffalo Bills | Occidental | PSA 8 | 405.00 | double print | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 37 | Paul Maguire | Buffalo Bills | Citadel | PSA 7 | 81.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 38 | Ron McDole | Buffalo Bills | Nebraska | PSA 8 | 1716.00 | rookie card | Oct 29 |
| 1965 Topps | 39 | George Saimes | Buffalo Bills | Michigan State | PSA 7 | 132.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 41 | Billy Shaw | Buffalo Bills | Georgia Tech | PSA 7 | 153.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 42 | Mike Stratton | Buffalo Bills | Tennessee | PSA 9 | 1240.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 43 | John Tracey | Buffalo Bills | Texas A and M | PSA 8 | 550.00 | Oct 29 | |
| 1965 Topps | 44 | Ernie Warlick | Buffalo Bills | North Carolina College | PSA 8 | 182.00 | double print | Oct 29 |
| 1967 Philadelphia | 107 | Mick Tingelhoff | Minnesota Vikings | Nebraska | PSA 9 | 242.00 | double print | Oct 29 |